NEARfest shoots their final hoop, hitting nothing but class
It was a great ending to probably the best and most highly regarded Progressive Rock festival in the country. It wasn’t the finest NEARfest, it wasn’t the worst and it wasn’t just average. But it was typical of what they have been doing for 14 years save one: Bringing in artists from across the progressive spectrum and across the globe, paying tribute to heritage artists and bringing in the next generation of progressive musicians.
WOW! BAND OF NEARFEST APOCALYPSE
Gösta Berlings Saga
BEST PERFORMANCE BY A BAND THAT SHOULD BE OVER THE HILL
Van Der Graaf Generator: Peter Hammill 63; Hugh Banton 63; Guy Evans 65
BEST PERFORMANCE BY A BAND WHO LOOKED LIKE THEY WERE PLAYING HOOKY FROM SCHOOL
Gösta Berlings Saga: Were their parents backstage?
MOST WORDY PERFORMANCE
A tie between Van Der Graaf Generator & Il Tempio Delle Clessidre
SPINAL TAP MOMENT
Il Tempio Delle Clessidre’s donning of masks, capes and hoods and pantomiming a battle in a song inspired by Witches. You could just see the dwarfs dancing around the miniature Stonehenge.
MOST 80s ERA MTV ROCK STAR ATTIRE
Twelfth Night: Marching band jacket, green and leather pants
MOST BIZARRE APPEARANCE
Il Tempio Delle Clessidre’s Elisa Montaldo sported what looked like a black Victorian funeral gown and matching hair comb although I don’t think they were showing leg through slit gowns then.
BAND THAT COULD BE MOST EASILY MISTAKEN FOR A CLASSICAL GROUP
Aranis
BAND THAT TOOK A WRONG TURN AT BONNAROO
The Mike Keneally Band
BAND THAT RECOVERED FROM A WEAK OPENING
Renaissance
FAVORITE STAGE QUOTE
“When you play three songs together you have a Prog Rock epic.”
Alexander Skepp of Gösta Berlings Saga
BEST FESTIVAL ADVICE
If you’re going to sell an extra ticket to somebody, make sure they aren’t a jerk. Thanks Mark, for not being a jerk.
DATED CONCEPT THAT SHOULD BE ABANDONED
Can the intro music. Renaissance rolled a full and corny orchestral version of one of their tunes. It’s tedious and doesn’t set a mood. It just gets people on edge watching an empty stage.
MOST UNEXPLAINED MISHAP
Speaking of empty stages, was there ever an explanation for the 90 plus minute delay of UK, followed by ten minutes of an empty, dimly lit stage? Even airlines have to give you a reason for a delay.
MOST CRIMINALLY NEGLECTED
Mark Wilkinson, who did one of the two NEARfest Apocalypse posters. He was selling them signed for $120, a totally reasonable price. But when I walked by mid-Sunday afternoon he had dropped the price to $60 because they weren’t moving. I got one.
MIA
Where was Roger Dean’s poster?
BEST AUDIENCE ON THE PLANET
Is there a better audience than the NEARfest crowd?. I don’t think so except for the two yahoos behind me who thought that the quiet parts of songs were there so they could talk. You know who I mean, Row N about seat 16 and 17.
HEAD-SCRATCHING FACT
Founders Chad Hutchinson and Rob LaDuca were both learning how to walk and talk during the glory years of Progressive Rock.
NEVER SAY NEVER
Asked the question whether they will come back for another year, Rob and Chad answered emphatically:
Rob: No!
Chad: No not tempted at all.
Rob: No.
Let’s see how they’re feeling round about October.
PARTING THOUGHT
I hope the 5-hour Energy Drink I gave the guy next to me helped him out on his four hour drive to Connecticut so he could be at work at 6AM Monday morning.
~© 2012 John Diliberto ((( echoes )))
You get great CDs like Todd Boston’s Touched by the Sun by becoming a member of the Echoes CD of the Month Club. Follow the link and see what you’ve been missing.
Todd Boston’s “Celtic Heart”
Join us on Facebook where you’ll get all the Echoes news.
Two Sides of Progressive Rock-Gentle Giant & Styx
October 16, 2012This past week saw a study in Progressive Rock contrasts when two bands from the classic progressive rock era, Three Friends, A.K.A. Gentle Giant and Styx came through the Philadelphia area.
Three Friends playing Gentle Giant at Sellersville Theater
Gentle Giant represented the adventurous experimental side of Progressive Rock, mixing jazz, blues, madrigals and classical music into a heady mix of time signature twisting grooves and melodically convoluted themes. Three Friends consists of one member from Gentle Giant’s founding, guitarist Gary Green and another from their early years, drummer Malcolm Mortimer, who was replaced in 1972 after a motorcycle accident. At Sellersville Theater they were rounded out by three “replacement” musicians who were by and large up to the task. The only problem was that the lead voice of Gentle Giant, Derek Shulman is not part of this enterprise. He was replaced by Pierre Bordeleau who was actually a substitute for Mick Wilson, who has been singing with the group but couldn’t make this gig. With a thin voice that has trouble hitting the high notes, Bordeleau isn’t quite up to the wild calliope singing of Derek Shulman, and his bemused stage presence just seemed wrong. It was like watching your high school science teacher.
There were many projections used during the show in a multi-image collage fashion. One of the most ironic was one of screaming girls at a concert. That’s the unfulfilled dream of many progressive rock groups, but not Styx, the early 70s prog-pop band who still has groupies in their audience and a line at the women’s bathroom (See joke: How do you know you’re at a progressive rock concert? There’s no line for the women’s restroom.)
Styx is currently on tour and this past Saturday the river flowed through the Sovereign Arts Performing Center in Reading, PA. Like Three Friends/Gentle Giant, there is one original member of the group, guitarist James Young and one later member, guitaristTommy Shaw. To my progressive ears in 1972 when the band debuted, Styx was always the poppy face of progressive rock. They were a band that took all of Prog’s complexities and carved them into digestible hook laced Top 4o tunes that eschewed Progs tendency towards multi-part compositions, improvised extrapolations and technical flash. In other words, they sold a lot more records than most, certainly more than Gentle Giant and they played to a 9000 seat house while Three Friends/Gentle Giant had an intimate audience of about 200. But Styx’s keyboard and guitar infused songs with soaring vocal harmonies did draw justified comparisons with bands like Yes. I didn’t go see them, but erstwhile 70s rock fan and Echoes Operations Manager Lori Daniels crossed the River Styx.
How can you tell if a band is progressive rock? If the audience isn’t dancing.
You can hear an interview with Gentle Giant on the Echoes Podcast.
~© 2012 John Diliberto ((( echoes )))
You get great CDs like these and our October CD Club selection, Hans Christian & Harry Manx’s You Are the Music of My Silence by becoming a member of the Echoes CD of the Month Club. Follow the link and see what you’ve been missing.
Join us on Facebook where you’ll get all the Echoes news so you won’t be left behind Dead Can Dance appear on the show, Tangerine Dream tours the states or Eno releases a
Share this:
Like this:
Tags:Gentle Giant, Nearfest, Styx, Three Friends
Posted in Interviews, Reviews & Commentary | 7 Comments »